About a week ago both the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal devoted considerable space to the coverage of ‘Parade,’ the revival of a 1998 Broadway musical on the 1915 killing of Leo Frank, a Jewish factory manager in Atlanta, Georgia, arguably the most famous lynching in American history. F…
American Pravda: The Leo Frank Case and the Origins of the ADL, by Ron Unz - The Unz Review Original textRate this translationYour feedback will be used to help improve Google Translatehttps://www.unz.com/runz/american-pravda-the-leo-frank-case-and-the-origins-of-the-adl/The Unz Review - MobileThe Unz Review • An Alternative Media Selection$A Collection of Interesting, Important, and Controversial Perspectives Largely Excluded from the American Mainstream Media User Settings: Version? DefaultUse DesktopUse MobileUse Tablet Social Media? AllNoneExclude Blogs Show Word Counts No Infinite Scrolling SaveCancelHomeAboutSettingsForeign PolicyRace/EthnicityCulture/SocietyIdeologyEconomicsArts/LettersScienceHistoryForumSummaryBloggersAll BloggersSteve Sailer's iSteve BlogAnatoly Karlin's Russian Reaction BlogPaul Kersey's SBPDL BlogSelected TweetersColumnistsAll ColumnistsRon UnzAndrew AnglinGilad AtzmonKevin BarrettJonathan CookJohn DerbyshirePepe EscobarPhilip GiraldiGregory HoodMichael Hudson Ilana MercerRon PaulTed RallPaul Craig RobertsLarry RomanoffIsrael ShamirEric StrikerJared TaylorJames ThompsonMike WhitneyNewslinksPodcastsPopularHTML BooksPDF ArchivesAnnouncementsArticlesAuthorsSubscribeMore...Most PopularPeriodicalsCommentsBanned BooksCollege Data SummaryCategoriesBloggersNewslinksColumnistsAuthorsSettingsAboutMore...Main FeaturesMastheadAnnouncementsSearchSubscribeBooksForumPodcastsArticle ArchivesPeriodicalsMost PopularComment ArchivesCollege Data← Filling the "Blank Spots" in Our Nation...Playing "Fool's Mate" on the Grand Eura... → BlogviewRon Unz Archive BlogviewRon Unz Archive Select Year/MonthAll Years = 727 ItemsDecade 2020s = 141 Items Year 2023 = 56 Items January 2023 = 7 Items February 2023 = 6 Items March 2023 = 5 Items Current Item April 2023 = 4 Items May 2023 = 5 Items June 2023 = 5 Items July 2023 = 6 Items August 2023 = 6 Items September 2023 = 5 Items October 2023 = 3 Items November 2023 = 4 Items Year 2022 = 45 Items Year 2021 = 23 Items Year 2020 = 17 ItemsDecade 2010s = 180 Items Year 2019 = 7 Items Year 2018 = 21 Items Year 2016 = 26 Items Year 2015 = 2 Items Year 2014 = 23 Items Year 2013 = 40 Items Year 2012 = 41 Items Year 2011 = 4 Items Year 2010 = 16 ItemsDecade 2000s = 233 Items Year 2009 = 2 Items Year 2008 = 5 Items Year 2007 = 2 Items Year 2005 = 1 Item Year 2004 = 6 Items Year 2003 = 8 Items Year 2002 = 62 Items Year 2001 = 65 Items Year 2000 = 82 ItemsDecade 1990s = 153 Items Year 1999 = 48 Items Year 1998 = 47 Items Year 1997 = 36 Items Year 1996 = 1 Item Year 1995 = 7 Items Year 1994 = 8 Items Year 1993 = 4 Items Year 1992 = 2 ItemsDecade 1980s = 20 Items Year 1986 = 4 Items Year 1985 = 3 Items Year 1984 = 7 Items Year 1983 = 4 Items Year 1982 = 1 Item Year 1981 = 1 Item--- November 2023 = 4 Items October 2023 = 3 Items September 2023 = 5 Items August 2023 = 6 Items July 2023 = 6 Items June 2023 = 5 Items May 2023 = 5 Items April 2023 = 4 Items March 2023 = 5 Items Current Item February 2023 = 6 Items January 2023 = 7 Items December 2022 = 4 Items November 2022 = 4 Items October 2022 = 5 Items September 2022 = 4 Items August 2022 = 7 Items July 2022 = 4 Items June 2022 = 1 Item May 2022 = 3 Items April 2022 = 3 Items March 2022 = 3 Items February 2022 = 3 Items January 2022 = 4 Items December 2021 = 4 Items November 2021 = 1 Item October 2021 = 3 Items September 2021 = 1 Item August 2021 = 4 Items July 2021 = 2 Items June 2021 = 1 Item May 2021 = 3 Items March 2021 = 1 Item February 2021 = 1 Item January 2021 = 2 Items November 2020 = 2 Items October 2020 = 1 Item September 2020 = 2 Items August 2020 = 2 Items July 2020 = 3 Items May 2020 = 3 Items April 2020 = 1 Item March 2020 = 2 Items January 2020 = 1 Item September 2019 = 1 Item July 2019 = 2 Items June 2019 = 1 Item May 2019 = 1 Item March 2019 = 1 Item January 2019 = 1 Item December 2018 = 2 Items November 2018 = 1 Item October 2018 = 3 Items September 2018 = 2 Items August 2018 = 2 Items July 2018 = 5 Items June 2018 = 5 Items May 2018 = 1 Item October 2016 = 2 Items September 2016 = 4 Items August 2016 = 6 Items July 2016 = 3 Items May 2016 = 2 Items April 2016 = 3 Items March 2016 = 3 Items February 2016 = 2 Items January 2016 = 1 Item March 2015 = 2 Items August 2014 = 2 Items July 2014 = 1 Item May 2014 = 5 Items April 2014 = 2 Items March 2014 = 4 Items February 2014 = 6 Items January 2014 = 3 Items December 2013 = 3 Items November 2013 = 1 Item July 2013 = 2 Items June 2013 = 2 Items May 2013 = 7 Items April 2013 = 7 Items March 2013 = 8 Items February 2013 = 6 Items January 2013 = 4 Items December 2012 = 5 Items November 2012 = 3 Items October 2012 = 4 Items September 2012 = 4 Items August 2012 = 7 Items July 2012 = 5 Items June 2012 = 2 Items May 2012 = 4 Items April 2012 = 4 Items January 2012 = 3 Items October 2011 = 1 Item September 2011 = 3 Items November 2010 = 1 Item October 2010 = 1 Item May 2010 = 3 Items March 2010 = 6 Items February 2010 = 4 Items January 2010 = 1 Item May 2009 = 1 Item March 2009 = 1 Item November 2008 = 1 Item September 2008 = 1 Item August 2008 = 1 Item March 2008 = 1 Item January 2008 = 1 Item August 2007 = 1 Item January 2007 = 1 Item March 2005 = 1 Item May 2004 = 2 Items April 2004 = 2 Items February 2004 = 1 Item January 2004 = 1 Item December 2003 = 1 Item April 2003 = 2 Items March 2003 = 3 Items February 2003 = 2 Items November 2002 = 2 Items October 2002 = 8 Items September 2002 = 6 Items August 2002 = 8 Items July 2002 = 5 Items June 2002 = 4 Items May 2002 = 4 Items April 2002 = 9 Items March 2002 = 3 Items February 2002 = 5 Items January 2002 = 8 Items December 2001 = 7 Items November 2001 = 6 Items October 2001 = 6 Items August 2001 = 6 Items July 2001 = 7 Items June 2001 = 3 Items May 2001 = 8 Items April 2001 = 4 Items March 2001 = 4 Items February 2001 = 6 Items January 2001 = 8 Items December 2000 = 5 Items November 2000 = 5 Items October 2000 = 10 Items September 2000 = 8 Items August 2000 = 11 Items July 2000 = 8 Items June 2000 = 11 Items May 2000 = 6 Items April 2000 = 6 Items March 2000 = 4 Items February 2000 = 5 Items January 2000 = 3 Items December 1999 = 4 Items October 1999 = 5 Items September 1999 = 1 Item August 1999 = 3 Items July 1999 = 6 Items June 1999 = 6 Items May 1999 = 5 Items March 1999 = 4 Items February 1999 = 6 Items January 1999 = 8 Items December 1998 = 2 Items November 1998 = 1 Item October 1998 = 4 Items September 1998 = 2 Items August 1998 = 2 Items July 1998 = 2 Items June 1998 = 1 Item May 1998 = 12 Items April 1998 = 6 Items March 1998 = 8 Items February 1998 = 2 Items January 1998 = 5 Items December 1997 = 2 Items November 1997 = 6 Items October 1997 = 8 Items September 1997 = 3 Items August 1997 = 6 Items July 1997 = 9 Items June 1997 = 1 Item May 1997 = 1 Item April 1996 = 1 Item July 1995 = 1 Item June 1995 = 1 Item May 1995 = 2 Items March 1995 = 2 Items January 1995 = 1 Item December 1994 = 1 Item November 1994 = 2 Items October 1994 = 1 Item September 1994 = 1 Item July 1994 = 2 Items May 1994 = 1 Item July 1993 = 1 Item May 1993 = 3 Items November 1992 = 1 Item August 1992 = 1 Item May 1986 = 2 Items March 1986 = 1 Item February 1986 = 1 Item November 1985 = 1 Item October 1985 = 1 Item March 1985 = 1 Item December 1984 = 1 Item August 1984 = 1 Item July 1984 = 1 Item June 1984 = 3 Items May 1984 = 1 Item October 1983 = 1 Item April 1983 = 1 Item March 1983 = 1 Item February 1983 = 1 Item March 1982 = 1 Item August 1981 = 1 ItemAmerican Pravda: The Leo Frank Case and the Origins of the ADL • 37m Ron Unz • March 27, 2023 • 5,300 Words • 733 Comments • ReplyTweetRedditShareShare9EmailPrintMore9 Shares RSS Share to GabEmail This Page to SomeoneYour Name Message Included Remember My InformationHere's something interesting from The Unz Review...Recipient Name Recipient Email(s), separated by semicolons => List of BookmarksLeo Frank. Credit: Wikimedia Commons◄►Bookmark◄►▲ ▼Toggle AllToC▲▼Add to LibraryRemove from Library • B Show CommentNext New CommentNext New ReplyRead MoreReplyAgree/Disagree/Etc. More... This Commenter This Thread Hide Thread Display All CommentsAgreeDisagreeThanksLOLTrollThese buttons register your public Agreement, Disagreement, Thanks, LOL, or Troll with the selected comment. They are ONLY available to recent, frequent commenters who have saved their Name+Email using the 'Remember My Information' checkbox, and may also ONLY be used three times during any eight hour period.Ignore Commenter Follow Commenter Search Text Case Sensitive Exact Words Include Comments SearchClearCancel Audio Playerhttps://www.unz.com/CONTENTS/AUDIO/runz/Unz-AmPravda-LeoFrank.mp300:0000:0000:00Use Up/Down Arrow keys to increase or decrease volume. EPub FormatAbout a week ago both the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal devoted considerable space to the coverage of “Parade,” the revival of a 1998 Broadway musical on the 1915 killing of Leo Frank, a Jewish factory manager in Atlanta, Georgia, arguably the most famous lynching in American history. Frank had been convicted and sentenced to death for the rape and murder of a young girl in his employ and the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) was founded in an effort to save his life. After numerous legal appeals failed, the state’s governor eventually commuted Frank’s sentence and a group of outraged citizens responded by hanging Frank. The incident was portrayed in both the musical and the associated media coverage as a particularly horrifying example of American anti-Semitism. Micaela Diamond and Ben Platt in “Parade” at the Bernard B. Jacobs Theater. However, the actual facts of that case were quite different than that and in 2018 I’d discussed them at considerable length as part of a longer article. Given the recently renewed spotlight on the issue and the fascinating implications of the true story, I’ve decided to extract and republish my analysis in hopes of bringing it to wider current attention. Although I had long recognized the power and influence of the ADL, a leading Jewish-activist organization whose officials were so regularly quoted in my newspapers, until rather recently I had only the vaguest notions of its origins. I’m sure I’d heard the story mentioned at some point, but the account had never stuck in my mind. Then perhaps a year or two ago, I happened to come across some discussion of the ADL’s 2013 centenary celebration, in which the leadership reaffirmed the principles of its 1913 founding. The initial impetus had been the vain national effort to save the life of Leo Frank, a young Southern Jew unjustly accused of murder and eventually lynched. In the past, Frank’s name and story would have been equally vague in my mind, only half-remembered from my introductory history textbooks as one of the most notable early KKK victims in the fiercely anti-Semitic Deep South of the early twentieth century. However, not long before seeing that piece on the ADL I’d read Albert Lindemann’s highly-regarded study The Jew Accused, and his short chapter on the notorious Frank case had completely exploded all my preconceptions. ORDER IT NOW First, Lindemann demonstrated that there was no evidence of any anti-Semitism behind Frank’s arrest and conviction, with Jews constituting a highly-valued element of the affluent Atlanta society of the day, and no references to Frank’s Jewish background, negative or otherwise, appearing in the media prior to the trial. Indeed, five of the Grand Jurors who voted to indict Frank for murder were themselves Jewish, and none of them ever voiced regret over their decision. In general, support for Frank seems to have been strongest among Jews from New York and other distant parts of the country and weakest among the Atlanta Jews with best knowledge of the local situation. Furthermore, although Lindemann followed the secondary sources he relied upon in declaring that Frank was clearly innocent of the charges of rape and murder, the facts he recounted led me to the opposite conclusion, seeming to suggest strong evidence of Frank’s guilt. When I much more recently read Lindemann’s longer and more comprehensive historical study of anti-Semitism, Esau’s Tears, I noticed that his abbreviated treatment of the Frank case no longer made any such claim of innocence, perhaps indicating that the author himself might have also had second thoughts about the weight of the evidence. Based on this material, I voiced that opinion in my recent article on historical anti-Semitism, but my conclusions were necessarily quite tentative since they relied upon Lindermann’s summary of the information provided in the secondary sources he had used, and I had the impression that virtually all those who had closely investigated the Frank case had concluded that Frank was innocent. But after my piece appeared, someone pointed me to a 2016 book from an unexpected source arguing for Frank’s guilt. Now that I have ordered and read that volume, my understanding of the Frank case and its historical significance has been entirely transformed. Mainstream publishers may often reject books that too sharply conflict with reigning dogma and sales of such works are unlikely to justify the extensive research required to produce the manuscript. Furthermore, both authors and publishers may face widespread vilification from a hostile media for taking such positions. For these reasons, those who publish such controversial material will often be acting from deep ideological motives rather than merely seeking professional advancement or monetary gain. As an example, it took a zealous Trotskyite leftist such as Lenni Brenner to brave the risk of ferocious attacks and invest the time and effort to produce his remarkable study of the crucial Nazi-Zionist partnership of the 1930s. And for similar reasons, we should not be totally surprised that the leading book arguing for the guilt of Leo Frank appeared as a volume in the series on the pernicious aspects of Jewish-Black historical relations produced by Louis Farrakhan’s Nation of Islam (NOI), nor that the text lacked any identified author. Anonymous works published by heavily-demonized religious-political movements naturally engender considerable caution, but once I began reading the 500 pages of Th… truncated (78,349 more characters in archive)