TextSearch

By Stuart Robbins My first post for SWIFT dealt with the apparent deathbed confessions of Boyd Bushman in which the alleged senior scientist for Lockheed Martin made vast claims about flying...

Debunkings are Part of the Conspiracy: A Follow-Up on the Boyd Bushman Alien Video Claims - JREF Home Swift About Education JREF Press Debunkings are Part of the Conspiracy: A Follow-Up on the Boyd Bushman Alien Video Claims 12/31/2014   By Stuart RobbinsMy first post for SWIFT dealt with the apparent deathbed confessions of Boyd Bushman in which the alleged senior scientist for Lockheed Martin made vast claims about flying saucers, aliens, and other related topics. That post focused on why I find deathbed confessions, in general, to be unconvincing.The Bushman story got a lot of press in the weeks that followed. It was trumpeted on many websites and blogs as well as radio shows. One of them was an interview of David Sereda, conducted by George Noory on November 2, 2014, on the late-night paranormal radio program Coast to Coast AM (C2C). C2C currently describes Mr. Sereda on their website as a "scientist, filmmaker, and spiritual explorer." Mr. Sereda could best be categorized as a "new age" person, and if you are interested in some of his claims, I invite you to look towards the two episodes of my podcast that I devoted to his ideas (part 1, part 2). Suffice it to say, he makes a lot of paranormal claims, but his evidence for them is severely lacking. Perhaps it's because he claims that people - including himself - only use 5% of their brain.Subtle digs and background information aside, Mr. Sereda had a different take on the Bushman story. Mr. Sereda claimed to have met Bushman many times and that he interviewed him in 2007 for a documentary (that Mr. Sereda has yet to release).Besides background information into the scientist (which goes against some claims that the Boyd Bushman shown in the "confessions" was not the "real" Bushman who worked at Lockheed Martin), Mr. Sereda had a different take on the claimed photos of the aliens that Bushman presented. Specifically in the recordings, Bushman showed photographs that he claimed were of aliens. The internet quickly erupted with photos of identical "aliens;" too bad they were plastic dolls.And so, that claim at least appeared to be debunked. And, if he's showing photos of plastic dolls and claiming they are real, it does cast a bad light on the rest of Bushman's claims. (Even though we should, if we were to be 100% fair, evaluate each individual claim in isolation.)But, Mr. Sereda had an answer to this: The dolls were made by disinformation people. To quote from the C2C description of the evening's show: Bushman alleged he had true photographs of the preserved alien from Roswell, and Sereda concluded there was possibly some authenticity to his claims, as the face in the Bushman photo contained unique irregularities, while the knock-off dolls, sold at places like K-mart, could have been part of a smear or disinformation campaign to discredit the actual photo. Further, Sereda suggested that the alien body was likely preserved with chemicals and plastics, creating the effect of the darkened eyes and rings around them, as fluid was lost from the body. That's right. Way back in the day after the aliens were brought to Area 51 (or, actually, the real Area 51 in Wright Patterson Air Force Base in Ohio), the Men in Black anticipated that someone would leak photos of the aliens. That over the next several decades, a vast "disclosure" network would grow and find these photos and present them as evidence of aliens landing. But, to counteract that effort by the not-yet-created disclosure movement, the Men in Black decided that the best way to confuse the issue would be to create dolls of the real aliens. And, they chose plastic not because it was cheap, but because the preservation method used at the time on the aliens rendered a plastic-like appearance (or maybe it was a happy coincidence). That way, when the real alien photos were leaked, the silly debunkers would point to the dolls and say that the real alien photos are just photos of dolls. [Cue evil laughter.]I kid you not.Thus goes the conspiracy mindset, and it's something that I think I first heard from Dr. Steve Novella: Once you get deep enough and invested enough in the conspiracy, nothing can persuade you that you are wrong. All evidence for the conspiracy is of course evidence for the conspiracy. But, all evidence against the conspiracy was planted by disinformation agents, and therefore it, too, is evidence for the conspiracy. Dr. Stuart J. Robbins is a research scientist who studies planetary geophysics with an emphasis on impact craters.  He writes and podcasts at “Exposing PseudoAstronomy” where he explores and discusses claims related to astronomy, geology, and physics; his writing here is done in cooperation with that endeavor.  On Twitter, he is @DrAstroStu. Comments are closed. SWIFT is named after Jonathan Swift, the author of Gulliver's Travels. In the book, Gulliver encounters among other things a floating island inhabited by spaced-out scientists and philosophers who hardly deal with reality. Swift was among the first to launch well-designed critiques against the flummery - political, philosophical, and scientific - of his time, a tradition that we hope to maintain at The James Randi Foundation. Categories All Cherry Teresa Doubtful News Everett Themer Faith Healing Guest Posts Guy Chapman Harriet Hall James Randi Kenny Biddle Leo Igwe Letters Paranormal Pseudoscience Psychics Science Based Medicine Sharon Hill Skepticism SkepVet Stuart Robbins Superstition & Belief TAM 2013 TAM 2014 UFOs William London Archives March 2015 February 2015 January 2015 December 2014 November 2014 October 2014 September 2014 August 2014 The James Randi Educational FoundationE-mail | [email protected] JREF Privacy Policy | Copyright © 2015 James Randi Educational Foundation. All Rights Reserved. About About James Randi The Million Dollar Challenge Our Financials Education Educational Modules Educational Videos & Podcasts Encyclopedia of Claims E-Books