Douglas Feith is a professor at Georgetown University and a visiting fellow at the Hoover Institution. From 2001 to 2005 he served as Under Secretary of Defense for Policy, reporting directly to the Secretary of Defense. He is the author of War and Decision: Inside the Pentagon at the Dawn of the...
Douglas Feith | Hoover Institution Events Student Opportunities About Hoover About Hoover Located on the campus of Stanford University and in Washington, DC, the Hoover Institution is the nation’s preeminent research center dedicated to generating policy ideas that promote economic prosperity, national security, and democratic governance. Learn More The Hoover Story Hoover Timeline & History Mission Statement Vision of the Institution Today Key Focus Areas Topics Who we are About our Fellows Leadership Research Programs Annual Reports Overseers Hoover in DC News Events Contact Us Careers Fellowship Opportunities Visit Hoover David and Joan Traitel Building & Rental Information Newsletter Subscriptions Connect With Us Student Opportunities Fellows Fellows Hoover scholars form the Institution’s core and create breakthrough ideas aligned with our mission and ideals. What sets Hoover apart from all other policy organizations is its status as a center of scholarly excellence, its locus as a forum of scholarly discussion of public policy, and its ability to bring the conclusions of this scholarship to a public audience. View All Fellows Featured Fellows Peter Berkowitz Norman M. Naimark Lee Ohanian Steven Koonin Michael McConnell Bruce Thornton Michael S. Bernstam View All Research Programs Overview China's Global Sharp Power Project Economic Policy Group History Working Group Hoover Education Success Initiative National Security Task Force National Security, Technology & Law Working Group Middle East and the Islamic World Working Group Military History/Contemporary Conflict Working Group Renewing Indigenous Economies Project State & Local Governance Strengthening US-India Relations Technology, Economics, and Governance Working Group Taiwan in the Indo-Pacific Region View All Featured Work Read More Books by Hoover Fellows Read More Economics Working Papers Read More Hoover Education Success Initiative | The Papers Fellowship Opportunities Overview Hoover Fellows Program National Fellows Program Student Fellowship Program Veteran Fellowship Program Congressional Fellowship Program Media Fellowship Program Silas Palmer Fellowship Economic Fellowship Program test Research Research Throughout our over one-hundred-year history, our work has directly led to policies that have produced greater freedom, democracy, and opportunity in the United States and the world. Learn More Focus Areas Overview Determining America’s Role in the World Answering Challenges to Advanced Economies Empowering State and Local Governance Revitalizing History Confronting and Competing with China Revitalizing American Institutions Understanding Public Opinion Understanding the Effects of Technology on Economics and Governance Topics Overview Economics Education Energy & Environment Health Care History Immigration International Affairs Key Countries / Regions Law & Policy Politics & Public Opinion Science & Technology Security & Defense State & Local Publications Books by Fellows Essays Published Works by Fellows Working Papers Congressional Testimony Hoover Press PERIODICALS Eureka Strategika The Caravan Research Programs Overview China's Global Sharp Power Economic Policy History Lab History Working Group Hoover Education Success Initiative Global Policy & Strategy National Security, Technology & Law Middle East and the Islamic World Military History & Contemporary Conflict Renewing Indigenous Economies State and Local Governance Strengthening US-India Relations Technology, Economics, and Governance Taiwan in the Indo-Pacific Region View All test Commentary Commentary Hoover scholars offer analysis of current policy challenges and provide solutions on how America can advance freedom, peace, and prosperity. Learn More Focus Areas Overview Answering Challenges to Advanced Economies Determining America’s Role in the World Empowering State and Local Governance Revitalizing History Confronting and Competing with China Revitalizing American Institutions Understanding Public Opinion Understanding the Effects of Technology on Economics and Governance Topics Overview Economics Education Energy & Environment Health Care History Immigration International Affairs Key Countries / Regions Law & Policy Politics & Public Opinion Science & Technology Security & Defense State & Local Publications Overview China Global Sharp Power Weekly Alert Email newsletters Hoover Daily Report Subscription to Email Alerts Periodicals California on Your Mind Defining Ideas Hoover Digest View All Multimedia Overview Video Series Uncommon Knowledge Battlegrounds GoodFellows PolicyEd Hoover Events Capital Conversations Hoover Book Club View All AUDIO PODCASTS Matters of Policy & Politics Economics, Applied EconTalk Secrets of Statecraft Law Talk Pacific Century Libertarian View All test Library & Archives Support Hoover Support Hoover Learn more about joining the community of supporters and scholars working together to advance Hoover’s mission and values. Learn More Events Student Opportunities MyHoover MyHoover What is MyHoover? MyHoover delivers a personalized experience at Hoover.org. In a few easy steps, create an account and receive the most recent analysis from Hoover fellows tailored to your specific policy interests. Watch this video for an overview of MyHoover. Create Account Log In to MyHoover Sign in with Google Your Email Password Forgot Password? Log In Forgot Password Login? Recover MyHoover MyHoover What is MyHoover? MyHoover delivers a personalized experience at Hoover.org. In a few easy steps, create an account and receive the most recent analysis from Hoover fellows tailored to your specific policy interests. Watch this video for an overview of MyHoover. Create Account Log In to MyHoover Your Email Password Forgot Password? Log In Don't have an account? Sign up OR Sign in with Google Have questions? Contact us Forgot Password Login? Recover Support Hoover Support Hoover Learn more about joining the community of supporters and scholars working together to advance Hoover’s mission and values. Learn More Support the Mission of the Hoover Institution Subscribe to the Hoover Daily Report Follow Hoover on Social Media Make a Gift Your gift helps advance ideas that promote a free society. Donate Now Explore About Hoover Institution Meet Our Fellows Hoover Daily Report Focus Areas Hoover in DC Research Teams Library & Archives 97,391 results found for "" Fellows 653 Results 653 «‹1234567›» 1 - 327 View All Jay Bhattacharya Senior Fellow Jay Bhattacharya, M.D., is a senior fellow (courtesy) at the Hoover Institution. Previously, he was a research fellow at the Hoover Institution. He is a professor at Stanford University Medical School. Thomas Hazlett Visiting Fellow Commentary 83,062 Results 83062 «‹1234567›» 1 - 41531 View All Read More Articles The Future Of Technology And National Security: The 17th Benjamin Franklin Award Celebration The seventeenth Benjamin Franklin Award recipient, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of General Dynamics Phebe N. Novakovic will discuss this year’s theme, “The Future of Technology and National Security” with LTG (ret.) H.R. McMaster, former US national security advisor. December 13, 2023 mentioning H.R. McMaster Read More Articles The Complex Domestic Politics Of US-China Relations While geopolitical tensions continue to define much of the U.S.-China relationship, changing domestic politics in both countries — often underappreciated and little understood — have become a major factor in this great power rivalry. Over the past decade, domestic political forces in both countries have had increasingly negative impacts on U.S.-China ties further exacerbating difficult relations between the two. December 8, 2023 mentioning Elizabeth Economy Research 1,461 Results 1461 «‹1234567›» 1 - 731 View All Read More Books The End of Everything: How Wars Descend into Annihilation A New York Times–bestselling historian charts how and why societies from ancient Greece to the modern era chose to utterly destroy their foes, and warns that similar wars of obliteration are possible in our time May 7, 2024 by Victor Davis Hanson Read More Books Getting Monetary Policy Back on Track Experts in economic policy debate the 2021 surge in inflation, why the Federal Reserve was slow to respond, and whether rule-like policy is the best approach to controlling inflation. March 1, 2024 by Michael D. Bordo, John H. Cochrane, John B. Taylor Library & archives 198 Results 198 «‹1234567›» 1 - 99 View All Workshop on Modern China and Taiwan September 1, 2023 by Maryann Japan and Japanese Diaspora Collections Major topics of the Japan collection include the Sino-Japanese War of 1894–95; pre–World War II domestic affairs; Japanese-sponsored governments in China, Taiwan, and Southeast Asia; the post–World War II Allied occupation, the International Military Tribunal for the Far East, the US-Japan Security Treaty. Records of the Japanese Communist Party and proceedings of the Imperial Diet, 1890–1946, are available. The Japanese Diaspora collection includes the Hoji Shinbun Digital Collection, the world’s largest open-access full-image digital collection of Japanese newspapers published in North America. August 3, 2023 by Lisa Nguyen All sections 97,391 Results 97391 «‹1234567›» 1 - 48696 View All Read More Event Social Security And Trends In Wealth Inequality Sylvain Catherine, assistant professor of Finance at the University of Pennsylvania Wharton School of Business, discussed “Social Security and Trends in Wealth Inequality,” a paper with Max Miller (Harvard University), and Natasha Sarin (Yale University). November 30, 2023 Read More Event TBD The October 7, 2023, Hamas attacks on Israeli civilians, and the worldwide moral outrage that that day’s savagery generated were only paralleled by a gleeful schadenfreude that overtook many European capitals and other places around the globe, from the Arab world to the United States to American university campuses outright celebrating the greatest loss in Jewish life since the Holocaust. What is the root cause of such stark, vile dichotomies when it comes to Israel, pitting on the one hand a camp of empathy and on the other one of resentment? How is it that alongside Western sympathizers there are always those depicting Israel as the eternal offender, forbidden from defending itself, even at the risk of being depicted in the most hideous of antisemitic tropes? Conversely, why is it that among Arabs and Muslims, Palestinians are consistently, uncritically, portrayed as eternal victims, beatific casualties of Israeli Apartheid who can do no wrong, and whose own brutality is the justifiable result of grievances long unheeded and a righteous legitimate expression of self-defense? What follows is an attempt to understand the intractable nature of the Arab-Israeli conflict and the divisiveness that it generates around the world. I will try to explain not by taking sides, not by passing a sentence on who is right and who is wrong, not by drawing Manichaean fault lines between Good and Evil, and not by proceeding from the premise of the militant Zionist or the Arabist activist. In this, I shall assume the role of a historian recounting a complex story, probing its details, interrogating its players, exploring their languages and their languages’ connotations, and interpreting the whole in an intelligible voice devoid of the prevailing Wokeist frills of our times. I shall do that while remaining mindful of this story’s challenges, avoiding its ideological partis pris, and steering clear of the tendency to discard nuances and realities for the sake of soothing emotions and mythologies. In the end, there are “origin stories” to this conflict that ought to come to the fore, ones that are often scorned in favor of resentments, platitudes, political correctness, and the human condition’s natural urge for settling scores. One Origin Story Let us begin with the lay of the land of today’s theater of conflict between Israelis and Palestinians, a quick, oversimplified lesson, as it were, in the history, geography, and toponymy of what is commonly referred to as the Arab-Israeli conflict. On the eve of the Great War, the Levantine political entities known today as Israel, Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, and Palestine did not exist as distinct geographic, national, or administrative units. All were territories of the Ottoman Empire (1516-1918); all had inhabitants who were subjects of that empire; all flaunted no distinct identities of their own besides being on the one hand privileged Muslim members of the Umma (the “nation of Islam”) and on the other hand underprivileged Millets, which is to say non-Muslim Dhimmi peoples or “lesser nations,” living on sufferance in the “the abode of Islam.” Those Millets, in the main Christians and Jews, were subject to the Dhimma system: an institutionalized complex of legal, social, political, and cultural handicaps—“institutional racism” in the language of today’s virtuous bien-pensance, a form of “legal discrimination”—that guaranteed the Millets’ physical safety and ability to keep pre-Muslim traditions in return for fealty and submission to an otherwise hostile, predominantly Muslim, universe. Under this Dhimma arrangement, a “system of protection” as it is often described in tidy academic terminologies, Christians and Jews in the world of Islam were “tolerated” peoples denied political and cultural rights, disenfranchised in their own homelands, lands from which they’d been dispossessed by seventh-century Muslim conquerors—"colonial settlers” in the normative language of our times. Describing this system in the late Ottoman period, Lebanese historian Zeine Zeine noted that Christians and Jews were “tributary people whose life and property were safe only by the good pleasure of the Turkish authorities”; that they lived in “an inferior and humiliating position compared with the Muslims”; that they were forbidden from bearing arms or entering civil service; and that they had to be “outwardly distinguished by the colors of [their] dress, [their] headwear and [their] shoes.”[1] Zeine noted further that national identities as we understand them in the West did not exist in the Ottoman world: All the ties, relationships, and loyalties were denominational and religious, primarily Muslim [Jewish] or Christian ... National unity was impossible under the circumstances … The Arab Muslim, speaking of the Ottoman Empire, could say “it is also my Empire,” for it was a Muslim Empire and the Muslim felt at home in it. But the Christian [and the Jew] was conscious most of the time that he was only one of the ra‘iyyah.[2] But this system of unequal relationships between Ottoman Muslims and non-Muslims would come to an end in the Great War’s aftermath. Alongside its tragedies and losses, the War’s conclusion would also conduce to the “emancipation” of non-Muslims in Muslim lands. Having chosen wartime’s “losing team,” the Ottoman Empire was dissolved in October 1918, leading to the abrogation of the Millet system and the redesigning of the eastern provinces of the former Empire by Britain and France, the war’s “winning team.” This task was guaranteed by a regime known as the League of Nations Mandate system, the purpose of which had been to shepherd the former Ottoman subjects into modern “citizenship” and shape their newly redesigned territories into modern states. Thus, based on this arrangement, and under the auspices of the League of Nations (predecessor of today’s United Nations), France was given “Mandate” over the former Ottoman Provinces (Vilayets) of Beirut, Damascus, Aleppo, and the Sanjak of Mount-Lebanon, creating out of them what became known as Syria and Greater Lebanon (later tout court Lebanon). Concomitantly, Britain was assigned the former Ottoman Vilayets of Basra, Baghdad, and Mosul, stitching them together into today’s Iraq. Britain was likewise assigned the former Ottoman Sanjak of Jerusalem and the southern parts of the Vilayets of Beirut and Damascus, creating out of them what became known as Mandatory Palestine. Mandatory Palestine would undergo an additional makeover in 1921, creating from its eastern flank the Hashemite Kingdom of Transjordan, today’s Jordan. Therefore, prior to this arrangement, none of the states mentioned above existed. There was no Syria nor a distinct Syrian national identity to speak of, no Palestine nor a Palestinian national consciousness among Arabs, and, as modern Iraq’s travails keep reminding us, no distinct, unified Iraqi history, memory, or esprit de corps. What is more, most of these newly Mandated entities were assigned “national names” owed not to their own histories or languages, but to European (Anglo-French) toponymic and geographic habits, Western traditions not only reflecting a tenuous local authenticity but also affirming the origins of modern Middle Eastern states as Western spawns adhering to Western political models and national assumptions. There were of course notable exceptions. Egypt had always been Egypt. In Lebanon, or to be exact in Mount-Lebanon, there were Maronite Christians who had long viewed themselves as Lebanese with a separate non-Arab identity, members of a “Lebanese nation, distinguished by a … culture dating back to the Phoenicians.”[3] Finally, in the Holy Land, there were also local Levantine Jews who dreamt of the redemption of the Jewish people and their restitution to their ancestral homeland in the former Ottoman Sanjak of Jerusalem and the southern Vilayets of Beirut and Damascus.[4] But those were exceptions that confirmed the rule, the rule being that Palestine, among others, was a Western concept, a Western toponym, yielding a Western demonym that Europeans used in pre-modern times to mean “Jews,” not Arabs, and to which Arabs themselves would remain indifferent until 1948 at the very earliest. Onomastics of the Story To the points above, Bernard Lewis reiterates that modern Near Eastern political entities like Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, Palestine, Israel, and the rest all owe their names (and often their “national histories”) to Classical Antiquity or Biblical tradition, not to Arab or Muslim tradition. In this sense, Jordan, Israel, and Lebanon are names issuing from the Bible; Syria is of classical Greek provenance; Palestine is a Roman term assigned to Roman Judea after the AD 70 destruction of the Jewish Temple in Jerusalem. All five place names are spawns of November 29, 2023 Guest Contributor Douglas Feith Douglas Feith is a professor at Georgetown University and a visiting fellow at the Hoover Institution. From 2001 to 2005 he served as Under Secretary of Defense for Policy, reporting directly to the Secretary of Defense. He is the author of War and Decision: Inside the Pentagon at the Dawn of the War on Terrorism (Harper, 2008). Read More Explore Edit Filters Refine Results Date Range Date Range BY TYPE Select from the list… BY TOPIC Select from the list… BY PUBLICATION Select from the list… BY REGION Select from the list… BY RESEARCH TEAM Select from the list… BY KEY FOCUS AREAS Select from the list… Additional Filters Filtering By: Displaying of Sort by Date First Prevoius Next Last Research Published works by fellows Join the Hoover Institution’s community of supporters in ideas advancing freedom. Support With its eminent scholars and world-renowned library and archives, the Hoover Institution seeks to improve the human condition by advancing ideas that promote economic opportunity and prosperity while securing and safeguarding peace for America and all mankind. Key Site Sections About Hoover Research Commentary Fellows Library & Archives Support Hoover Search Quick Links Student Opportunities News Events Contact Us Hoover Daily Report Hoover Press Visit Visit Visit Visit Visit Visit Visit Vi… truncated (358 more characters in archive)