‘Dividing the bear’s skin while the bear is still alive’ - The National Archives blog This website uses cookies We place some essential cookies on your device to make this website work. We'd like to use additional cookies to remember your settings and understand how you use our services. This information will help us make improvements to the website. Accept cookiesReject cookiesSet cookie preferences Explore the collection A new way to find our highlights and stories – Try it now Skip to Main Content Menu Show search optionsShow search optionsEnter search keyword or keywordsSearch our website Show or hide search formSelect to search website or recordsSearch our websiteSearch our recordsEnter search keyword or keywordsSearch our website About us About us home Our role Visit us Opening times What’s on Exhibitions Events Get involved News Commercial opportunities Education Education home Time periods Lessons Workshops Professional development For teachers For students Help with your research Help with your research home Search Discovery, our catalogue Start your research here Research guides A-Z Online collections UK Government Web Archive British citizenship services Record copying Information management Information management home Guidance and standards A-Z Copyright How to manage your information Re-using PSI Producing official publications Legislation and regulations Training Archives sector Archives sector home Historical Manuscripts Commission Finding funding Projects and programmes Case studies and research reports Operating your archive Our role in the archives sector More… Shop Image library Blog Podcasts and videos Contact us Home > Blog > ‘Dividing the bear’s skin while the bear is still alive’ Select a category Select a category Archives and archivists Behind the scenes Managing information Records and research Technology and innovation Select month Select a month December 2023 (4) November 2023 (5) October 2023 (3) September 2023 (5) August 2023 (4) July 2023 (5) June 2023 (13) May 2023 (8) April 2023 (9) March 2023 (17) February 2023 (7) January 2023 (10) December 2022 (17) November 2022 (37) October 2022 (15) September 2022 (5) August 2022 (10) July 2022 (10) June 2022 (16) May 2022 (14) April 2022 (11) March 2022 (13) February 2022 (12) January 2022 (9) December 2021 (8) November 2021 (19) October 2021 (14) September 2021 (12) August 2021 (5) July 2021 (11) June 2021 (12) May 2021 (14) April 2021 (6) March 2021 (20) February 2021 (8) January 2021 (4) December 2020 (5) November 2020 (15) October 2020 (5) September 2020 (9) August 2020 (11) July 2020 (11) June 2020 (25) May 2020 (28) April 2020 (18) March 2020 (5) February 2020 (5) January 2020 (10) December 2019 (13) November 2019 (13) October 2019 (12) September 2019 (5) August 2019 (9) July 2019 (9) June 2019 (17) May 2019 (11) April 2019 (11) March 2019 (11) February 2019 (8) January 2019 (9) December 2018 (12) November 2018 (16) October 2018 (14) September 2018 (8) August 2018 (15) July 2018 (17) June 2018 (12) May 2018 (12) April 2018 (17) March 2018 (21) February 2018 (12) January 2018 (11) December 2017 (13) November 2017 (26) October 2017 (15) September 2017 (11) August 2017 (9) July 2017 (14) June 2017 (12) May 2017 (11) April 2017 (20) March 2017 (15) February 2017 (14) January 2017 (10) December 2016 (16) November 2016 (10) October 2016 (17) September 2016 (17) August 2016 (14) July 2016 (21) June 2016 (16) May 2016 (15) April 2016 (15) March 2016 (19) February 2016 (18) January 2016 (14) December 2015 (10) November 2015 (21) October 2015 (18) September 2015 (20) August 2015 (16) July 2015 (21) June 2015 (18) May 2015 (15) April 2015 (2) March 2015 (21) February 2015 (15) January 2015 (13) December 2014 (18) November 2014 (19) October 2014 (22) September 2014 (14) August 2014 (18) July 2014 (16) June 2014 (15) May 2014 (13) April 2014 (16) March 2014 (16) February 2014 (14) January 2014 (15) December 2013 (12) November 2013 (21) October 2013 (16) September 2013 (17) August 2013 (14) July 2013 (19) June 2013 (16) May 2013 (22) April 2013 (17) March 2013 (23) February 2013 (18) January 2013 (19) December 2012 (15) November 2012 (21) October 2012 (21) September 2012 (20) August 2012 (19) July 2012 (20) June 2012 (13) May 2012 (17) April 2012 (15) March 2012 (18) February 2012 (12) Select an author Select an author Adele BushadminAdrian AilesAdrian ChurchmanAlex GreenAlex LeighAlex RitchieAlexa PhillipsAlice MarplesAlison ArchibaldAllison MartinoAlon TamAmanda BevanAmanda SpencerAmy CoakerAmy GeeAmy GreirAmy HoweAmy SampsonAnastasia DonaldsonAndrea KocsisAndrew HarrisonAndrew HoltAndrew JanesAndrew R. LittleAngela CheungAngelina BakalarouAnn ChowAnna de SousaAnna Maria BarryAnnabel BaynesAnnamaria ValentAnne IrfanAnne-Lise DepoilAnne-Sophie GrollemundAnnette OrmanczykAnnick CossicAnnie DavisAnnika Pahlsson-GiddingsAnthony DayAntony BeevorArantza DobbelsAshley MarchAudrey CollinsBarbara PackardBarry PurdonBecky FarmerBen MacintyreBenjamin TrowbridgeBernard OgdenBeth BruntonBeth ElliottBethan DaviesBrendan KaneBriony PaxmanBruno DerrickBruno PappalardoCallum PearsCamilla Camus-DoughanCarianne WhitworthCarina RosasCarol KellasCaroline CatchpoleCaroline DCaroline HeilCaroline JamesCaroline PegdenCaroline WilliamsCarrie LongCatharine WilliamsCatherine FletcherCatherine TackleyCathy WilliamsCatt BaumCharles GreenCharlotte MarchantCharlotte SmithChloe LeeChris BarnesChris DayChris HeatherChris JonesChristine BerryChristine PetersClaire IzzardClaire KennanClaire NewingClare HorrieClarissa AngusCliff EdwardsCliff Van DortColin WilliamsDaniel GilfoyleDaniel GoslingDaniella Marie GonzalezDanielle Morgan-DoddDave WoodDavid ClipshamDavid GillDavid GillespieDavid LangrishDavid PerkinsDavid PriestDavid UnderdownDebbie HughesDiane RowlandDinah EastopDominic SandbrookDonald PhillipsDr Andrew HorrallDr Anna SextonDr Brenda MortimerDr Callan DaviesDr David ClarkeDr Eirini GoudarouliDr George HayDr Helen WilsonDr Hester VaizeyDr Jacqueline RidingDr Jessica LutkinDr Jessica NelsonDr Jonathan MackmanDr Joseph QuinnDr Juliette DesplatDr Katy MairDr Laura TompkinsDr Lora AngelovaDr Michael RobinsonDr Nick BarrattDr Richard DunleyDr Sean CunninghamDr Tony WakefordDr Valerie JohnsonDylan LawsonEd WoodhouseÉilis CroweEla KaczmarskaEleanor Johnson WardElena RossiElizabeth BiggsElizabeth Figura-DraneElizabeth GoldringElizabeth HainesElizabeth HendyElizabeth MicakovicEllie PengElspeth McgregorElspeth TolanEmilie CloosEmily BalsdonEmily DuttonEmily JenningsEmily McIntyreEmily MerittEmily MorrisEmily RumbleEmily StidstonEmily Ward-WillisEmma AllenEmma BayneEmma DownEmma Golby-KirkEmma JayEmma KayEmma MarkiewiczEmma SkinnerEmma StaggErica PeacockEtienne JosephEuan RogerFaith LawrenceFarid KarimFlo WatsonFrancesca BreedenFrancesca MackenzieGabrielle StoreyGary BrannanGary ThorpeGemma MartinGeoff PickGeorge JukesGillian GinesGrace IoppoloGraham JevonGus Casely-HayfordGwyn JonesHannah CarterHannah ClareHannah ForsytheHannah GriffithsHannah Leah CrumméHannah RiceHannah WorthenHannes KleinekeHarriet BarkerHarriet CraigHarriet GillespieHazel JellHelen Pye-SmithHolly SmithIan IrelandIan KirkpatrickIan MortimerIan StrawbridgeIlaria CocciaIoannis VasallosIqbal SinghIsabella WhitworthIsabelle Reynolds-LogueIsobel HunterJack AveryJacqueline MoonJake BickfordJames CronanJames FlemingJames TraversJane CarswellJane FloodJane GoldingJane LangfordJane LawrenceJane ShillakerJanet DempseyJasmine BendinelliJeff JamesJenni OrmeJenny BunnJenny ChildsJenny McHughJeremy BubbJessamy CarlsonJessica MinshullJessica SmithJim CostinJim WrethamJitske JasperseJo MoorsheadJo PughJoanna BlackburnJoanna TuckerJohn CaseyJohn GuyJohn MooreJohn SheridanJonathan CatesJonathan ColeJonathan LaddJordan FarrellJordan MegyeryJoseph McGrathJudith RileyJudy NokesJulie HallsJulie SteerJulie ThomsonJulie ZielstraJuliette JohnstoneJulius WelbyJustin LyonKaren StapleyKasia McCabeKate JarmanKate RoseKate SuttonKaterina WilliamsKatherine HowellsKathryn CollinsKathryn PhelpsKatie CholetteKatie CollinsKatie FlanaganKatie FoxKatrina LidbetterKaylara ReedKeith MitchellKerra PaternotteKerri RamsayKerstin DobleKevin ChambersKevin SearleKirsten ForrestKirstin BarnardKourosh FeissaliKyla HyslopLaura CowdreyLaura Robson-MainwaringLaura UglowLauren BailyLauren WillmottLee DurbinLee OliverLinda StewartLisa Berry-WaiteLiz Bryant (Admin)Liz FultonLouise BellLouise SeawardLucia Pereira PardoLucy AngusLucy BlandLucy MooreLydia BirchMairéad McCleanMajeda BegumMarcelle Cinq-MarsMarcus GoringeMareike BarnuschMargaret VosMaria CieslakMaria TroupkouMarianne WilsonMarilia TeixeiraMark BellMark DuntonMark JonesMark MerifieldMark PearsallMarta LomzaMartin FletcherMartin WillisMathilde GuilloMatt BlairMatt McGrattanMatt NormanMatthew GoodwinMatthew HillyardMax BamberMeada WadmanMeagen SmithMel DraperMelanie Backe-HansenMelinda HauntonMichael LittleMichael MahoneyMichael McGradyMichaela JonesMichele PiscitelliMichelle HuxterMihai DiaconitaMike EsbesterMillie FiltnessMollie ClarkeMolly BroughtonMontaz MarchéNancy BellNaomi LewisNaomi ReesNatalie BrownNathan SakerNeil BeagrieNeil CobbettNeil JohnstonNell DarbyNiall KeeganNicki WelchNicky CreweNicola FlemingNicola HurtNicola TallisNicola WelchNigel TaylorNoor SafiOliver FinneganOliver MorleyOlivia GecsegOlivia NorthropP E SzoradovaPad KumlertsakulPatricia AinelyPatricia ReynoldsPatrick RussellPaul BeardPaul CarterPaul DryburghPaul LameyPaul YoungPauline EliePauline LovenPawel JaskulskiPete SeamanPeter HelmorePhilip Clegg, MirrorWebPhilippa HellawellPhilippa MesianoPoppy SimpsonPortia TremlettPragya DhitalRachael MinottRachel ColeRachel HillmanRachel NewtonRachel SmillieRalph DayRalph ThompsonRandolph CockRaphaël BaumardRebecca EvansRebecca SimpsonRhea EversRhian AddisonRhys Thomas SpareyRichard ElvinRichard KnightRob JohnsonRobert HollandRobin P JenkinsRoger KershawRosalind FarrRose MitchellRose SinclairRosie MorrisRoss SpencerRuth FordRuth RobertsRuth SelmanS L GrangeSally HoultSally HughesSam BairstowSam ČermákSam MeunierSammy SturgessSandra ShakespeareSara GriffithsSarah AbbottSarah CastagnettiSarah FellowsSarah HendricksSarah HuttonSarah KoganSarah LeggettSarah MassSarah RadfordSarah VanSnickSarra HamdiSebastian SobeckiSharon McMeekinShaun EvansShona LoweSimon Boyd-SmithSimon DemissieSimon WilkesSolange FitzgeraldSonia RanadeStella MatthewsStephanie MarkinsStephen HuwsStephen McGannStephen PoleonStephen TwiggeSteve MannionSteven CableSteven FranklinSue HawkinsSusan HealySusan MooreTess NowellTessa ThomasThomasina SmithTim CallisterTom CharnockTom CraneTom StorrarTommy NortonTracey PowellVicky Iglikowski-BroadVictoria LainVikki CorkerWendy Tait MayfieldWilliam ButlerWilliam SpencerZoe Harrigan Search for: ‘Dividing the bear’s skin while the bear is still alive’ Monday 16 May 2016 | Dr Juliette Desplat | Archives and archivists | 4 comments 100 years ago, on 16 May 1916, Britain and France signed a secret agreement carving up the Ottoman Empire. Named after its creators, Mark Sykes (MP for Hull Central and attached to the Directorate of Military Operations) and François Georges-Picot (a French diplomat), the Sykes-Picot Agreement was never popular; it is still perceived today as a tangible manifestation of Anglo-French imperialist perfidy and the source of all troubles in the Middle East. Anticipating the defeat of the Ottoman Empire, and anxious to secure their foothold in the region, Britain and France started negotiating in 1915 to divide it up between themselves, ‘on the hypothesis that France and Britain [were] desirous of assisting in the creation of an Arab State or Confederation of Arab States.’ The first meeting, held on 23 November to ‘examine French and British desiderata in the Asiatic dominions of Turkey’ (CAB 42/11/9), wasn’t overwhelmingly positive. Picot, it seems, wasn’t very popular; ‘M. Picot is well known as being very extreme in his ideas,’ Clayton, the Director of British Military Intelligence in Cairo, wrote a few weeks after the meeting, ‘and completely saturated with the vision of a great French possession in the Eastern Mediterranean’ (FO 141/734/1). Clayton’s account of the meeting held on 23 November 1915 (catalogue reference: FO 141/734/1) Picot was admittedly rather uncompromising. Informed of ongoing negotiations between the High Commissioner in Egypt and the Sharif of Mecca about Arab nationalist aspirations, the French diplomat explained that France would ‘never consent to offer independence to the Arabs’, that Syria was ‘very near the heart of the French’ and that he had very little faith in the Arab nationalist movement Britain was trying to trigger. He also demanded the whole of Syria and Palestine for France. The negotiations, unsurprisingly, reached a deadlock at this point and Picot went back to Paris to lay the matter before his government. As Anglo-French rivalry is never very far, Clayton brought Fashoda back into the picture. He dismissed Picot as ‘one of the Anglophobe school of 1898’ (FO 882/12) and his arguments as ‘sentimental trash’ (FO 882/2). Clayton’s note on the minutes of the meeting held on 23 November 1915 (catalogue reference: FO 882/2) A second meeting was held on 21 December 1915. Picot arrived in London with scaled-down French demands. The British, however, suddenly announced they wanted the future Arab State to encompass Lebanon. Once again, the meeting broke up with no agreement. Sykes and Picot then met privately to discuss unresolved issues. Clayton thought it was ‘hopeless to attempt to arrive at any reasonable agreement with the French so long as Picot [was] their representative’ (FO 882/2), but a deal was finally reached on 3 February 1916 (CAB 42/11/9). The finalisation of the agreement was ‘contingent on the consent of Russia’, who had interests in the region, and on the cooperation of the Arabs, who had to implement the revolt they were promising. Sykes and Picot therefore proceeded to Petrograd to share the draft with the Foreign Minister, Sazonov. Russia having agreed (for a price, as it obtained large portions of Ottoman territory in the bargain, including Constantinople and the Straits) on 26 April 1916 (FO 371/2768), the final terms were sent by Paul Cambon, the French Ambassador in London, to the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs, Edward Grey, on 9 May 1916, and ratified in Grey’s reply on 16 May 1916 (FO 371/2777). Cambon to Grey, 09/05/1916, first and last pages (catalogue reference: FO 371/2177) The Sykes-Picot Agreement used Sykes’ line in the sand, ‘from the ‘e’ in ‘Acre to the last ‘k’ in Kerkuk’ (CAB 24/1/51) to divide the region into five zones: Zone A (covering the north of Syria and the province of Mosul): ‘an independent Arab State or a Confederation of Arab States (…) under the suzerainty of an Arab chief’ in which France would have ‘priority of right of enterprise and local loans’ and would ‘alone supply advisers or foreign functionaries’. Zone B (covering the south of Syria and Transjordan): ‘an independent Arab State or a Confederation of Arab States (…) under the suzerainty of an Arab chief’ in which Britain was to have the same rights. A Blue Zone (covering Lebanon and Cilicia), in which France ‘shall be allowed to establish such direct or indirect administration or control as [it desired] and as [it] may think fit to arrange with the Arab State or Confederation of Arab States.’ A Red Zone (covering Kuwait and Mesopotamia), in which Britain obtained similar rights. A Brown Zone (Palestine) where an ‘international administration’ was to be established, with Britain controlling the ports of Acre and Haifa. Map attached to the Sykes-Picot Agreement, signed by Mark Sykes and François Georges-Picot (catalogue reference: MPK 1/426) The agreement was to remain secret. The High Commissioner in Egypt wrote to the Foreign Office that while he felt confident noting in the agreement clashed with the promises made to Sharif Hussein to create an independent Arab State, he thought that ‘the moment [had] not yet arrived when we [could] safely [divulge the details of that arrangement] without some risk of misinterpretation by Arabs’ (FO 141/734/1). Hussein was eventually briefed in the spring of 1917 (FO 882/16), along with the Italians, who promptly demanded (and obtained) Western Anatolia (FO 93/48/60). So when the Bolsheviks, who had just deposed Tsar Nicholas II, found a copy of the agreement in the archives and leaked it to the press, it was probably not the massive shock they had hoped for. Although the French government considered the Sykes-Picot Agreement as ‘definitive’ and ‘final’ (CAB 17/176), the British had second thoughts very early on. Before it was even concluded, on 3 May 1916, Hogarth, the Head of the Arab Bureau, wrote: ‘I hope (…) this agreement is regarded by our Government as a purely opportunist measure with the mental reservation that it cannot but need considerable revision sooner or later’ (FO 882/14). In Cairo, Clayton agreed; he thought the agreement may be a ‘useful guide’ but noted that the situation in the Middle East was very unstable and that ‘anything more than an informal and general understanding would be dangerous’ (FO 371/2774). Similarly, Hall, the Director of Naval Intelligence, thought that it was rather like ‘dividing the bear’s skin while the bear is still alive’ (CAB 42/11/9). In April 1917, the War Cabinet suggested that the Agreement should be modified so as to give Britain ‘definite and exclusive control over Palestine’ (CAB 23/2/44). On 3 October 1918, the minutes of the War Cabinet recorded that: ‘the Prime Minister said he had been refreshing his memory about the Sykes Picot Agreement and had come to the conclusion that it was quite inapplicable to the present circumstances and was altogether a most undesirable agreement from a British point of view. Having been concluded more than 2 years ago, it entirely overlooked the fact that our position in Turkey had been won by very large British forces, whereas our Allies had contributed but little to the result’ (CAB 23/14/35). Lloyd George’s thoughts on the Sykes-Picot Agreement, 03/10/1918 (catalogue reference: CAB 24/8/3) The Agreement, drawing lines in the sand of the not quite moribund sick man of Europe, is largely perceived today as the source of all Middle Eastern dissent. 100 years on, it is probably time to move beyond the popular myth of Sykes-Picot, that no-so-secret agreement which did not shape the modern Middle East. The French did try to make it the basis of the Peace negotiations (CAB 23/12/7), but Sykes-Picot was never implemented. Let’s remember that it wasn’t an internationally binding treaty, but only an agreement which was deemed suitable at the time. Mark Sykes and François Georges-Picot did not determine borders in the regions, merely zones of influence; the borders themselves were fixed by the 1920 Treaty of Sèvres and the 1923 Treaty of Lausanne. They were quite different from what the Agreement had suggested – Mosul ended up in the British sphere of influence, Palestine became a British Mandate, Italy didn’t get Anatolia, Russia (who had withdrawn after th… truncated (3,904 more characters in archive)