TextSearch

Many decades ago, the Americans proposed to use nuclear weapons to blast a waterway through the Negev Desert. But the plan never progressed. This is why it did not — and why there is some talk about the ‘Ben Gurion Canal’ again as Israel pushes to destroy Hamas in Gaza

A plan to join the Red Sea with Mediterranean — an alternative to the Suez Canal | Explained News - The Indian Express Sections Englishதமிழ்বাংলাമലയാളംગુજરાતીहिंदीमराठीBusinessबिज़नेस Newsletters Tuesday, Jan 09, 2024 ePaper Today’s Paper Journalism of Courage HomeCitiesIndiaExplainedOpinionBusinessEntertainmentSportsPoliticsLifestyleTechEducationInvestigationsResearchVideosPodcast Subscribe Sign In Trending🎙️ 3 Things PodcastPlay CrosswordLatest NewsPremium StoriesUPSC SpecialHealth & WellnessLive TV Advertisement NewsExplainedExplained GlobalA plan to join the Red Sea with Mediterranean — an alternative to the Suez Canal Premium A plan to join the Red Sea with Mediterranean — an alternative to the Suez Canal Many decades ago, the Americans proposed to use nuclear weapons to blast a waterway through the Negev Desert. But the plan never progressed. This is why it did not — and why there is some talk about the ‘Ben Gurion Canal’ again as Israel pushes to destroy Hamas in Gaza Written by Arjun Sengupta New Delhi | November 10, 2023 14:45 IST Follow Us The Suez Canal through Egypt along with the proposed Ben-Gurion Canal through Israel occupied territory. (Wikimedia Commons) Listen to this article A plan to join the Red Sea with Mediterranean — an alternative to the Suez Canal x 00:00 1x 1.5x 1.8x It has been speculated that one of the reasons behind Israel’s desire to eliminate Hamas from the Gaza Strip and completely control the Palestinian enclave is to give itself the chance to better explore a dramatic economic opportunity that has been talked about for several decades, but for which peace and political stability in the region is an essential prerequisite. The idea is to cut a canal through the Israeli-controlled Negev Desert from the tip of the Gulf of Aqaba — the eastern arm of the Red Sea that juts into Israel’s southern tip and south-western Jordan — to the Eastern Mediterranean coast, thus creating an alternative to the Egyptian-controlled Suez Canal that starts from the western arm of the Red Sea and passes to the southeastern Mediterranean through the northern Sinai peninsula. Get unrestricted access to journalism Check out the ePaper + Premium combo plan. Subscribe Now Already a subscriber? Sign in A topographic map of the proposed Ben Gurion Canal. (Wikimedia Commons) This so-called Ben Gurion Canal Project, which was first envisioned in the 1960s would, if it were to be actually completed, transform global maritime dynamics by taking away Egypt’s monopoly over the shortest route between Europe and Asia. Advertisement However, any attempt to construct the canal would have to overcome gigantic logistical, political, and funding challenges which, in the current situation, makes it seem largely fantastical. We take a look at what has been proposed, and its implications, theoretically, on global trade and geopolitics. But first, a look at the Suez Canal’s salience. When it opened in 1869, the Suez Canal revolutionised global maritime trade. By connecting the Mediterranean and Red Seas through the Isthmus of Suez, it ensured that ships travelling between Europe and Asia would not have to travel all the way around the continent of Africa. The canal cut the distance between London and Bombay (now Mumbai) by a more than 41 per cent. The Suez Canal shortened the distance between Lonodn and Bombay by well over 4,000 nautical miles (1 nm = 1.852 km) (Wikimedia Commons) In the 2022-23 fiscal year, around 26,000 vessels crossed the Suez Canal, accounting for approximately 13 per cent of global shipping. Must Read | The History of the Suez Canal The canal, however, has its issues. First, the 193 km-long, 205 m-wide, and 24 m-deep Suez Canal is the world’s biggest shipping bottleneck. Despite being widened and deepened over the years, it remains perennially congested, with long queues at either end. In March 2021, the mammoth cargo ship Ever Given got stuck in the canal, blocking passage for more than a week. It was estimated that the resulting “traffic jam” held up an estimated $ 9.6 billion of goods every day.Advertisement Traffic on mouth of the Suez Canal after the Ever Given incident in 2021. (Wikimedia Commons) Also, Egypt’s control over the waterway has been a source of conflict for almost 70 years now. In 1956, after President Gamal Abdel Nasser (1918-70) decided to nationalise the canal, war broke out, with the UK, France, and Israel attacking Egypt in order to regain control. The Suez Crisis ended in a military victory for the aggressors but an overwhelming political victory for Egypt, which kept control over the canal, which was shut for more than six months due to the conflict. This was also a pivotal moment in the Cold War, with Soviet threats of intervention key to stopping the allied aggression against Egypt. The Suez Canal was also the focal point of both the 1967 and 1973 Arab-Israeli wars, and was shut from 1967-75.Advertisement The canal is, of course, critical to Egypt’s economy. It collects all the toll revenue generated, in addition to the benefits it brings to its local economy. In the 2022-23 fiscal year, Egypt’s Suez Canal Authority saw toll revenues reach a record $ 9.4 billion — accounting for nearly 2 per cent of Egypt’s GDP of $ 476.8 billion, according to the World Bank. Thus, for the West, a shipping lane through Israel would be ideal. It remains unclear when the first concrete plan for the alternative was suggested. The documented evidence can be seen in a declassified 1963 US government memorandum. The memo called for the use of nuclear explosives to dig the canal through the Negev Desert in Israel. “Another interesting application of nuclear excavation would be a sea level canal 160 miles long across Israel, connecting the Mediterranean with the Gulf of Aqaba (and thus the Red Sea and the Indian Ocean). Such a canal would be a strategically valuable alternative to the present Suez Canal and would probably contribute greatly to the economic development of the surrounding area,” the memo reads. Nuclear Explosives for evacuation of sea level canal by Express Web on Scribd The Ben Gurion Canal Project, named after Israel’s founding father David Ben-Gurion (1886-1973), remains one of the most ambitious infrastructure projects ever planned on paper.Advertisement What has stopped Israel from constructing the canal? First and foremost, such a project would be extremely complex and almost prohibitively expensive. The estimated cost of such a project may be as high as the $ 100 billion, much more than what it might take to widen the Suez Canal and solve its traffic problem. Must Read | Why Gaza is known as the world’s biggest ‘open air prison’ According to the previous cited memo, it was the cost of digging such a canal conventionally that made planners look at the nuclear option. Of course, the risk of nuclear fallout makes this option extremely risky as well.Advertisement Costs aside, the planned route of the Ben Gurion Canal is over 100 km longer than the Suez Canal, primarily due to limitations of the terrain and topography. Even if built, many ships might still favour the older, shorter route. Most importantly, however, a canal which will potentially transport billions of dollars worth of freight daily cannot run in land under constant military threat, from Hamas rockets or Israeli attacks. More Premium Stories Ex-envoy: ISI tipped off India about plot to hit KashmirPremium Story UPSC Key, January 9: What you should read today andPremium Story Why do politicians rush to give direct benefits (cash) toPremium Story The true story of the Jolly Joseph casePremium Story Uma Bharti interview: ‘We've no copyright on Ram Bhakti'Premium Story ‘Badalta Kashmir’: Meet rappers whose song on Valley is makingPremium Story 3-girl BTS army embarks on Seoul dream, rescued in ChennaiPremium Story Problems MAX: Why Alaska Airlines incident raises concern globallyPremium Story Tavleen Singh writes: Mixing religion with politics has ruined countriesPremium Story Vandita Mishra writes: A consecration in AyodhyaPremium Story Meet 'Magistrate Mariyakutty', who took on Kerala govt with beggingPremium Story Can Ram temple usher in resurgence with reconciliation?Premium Story © The Indian Express Pvt Ltd First uploaded on: 10-11-2023 at 14:45 IST Tags: Explained Global Express Explained Express Premium Gaza Israel Israel Palestine conflict Suez Canal Latest Comment Post Comment Read Comments AdvertisementMore ExplainedExplainedWho is the new PM of France, what changes with his appointmentExplainedHow Houthi attacks in Red Sea are different from Somali hijackingsExplainedBilkis Bano case: Remission quashed, what now for the convicts?ExplainedFirst US lunar lander since 1972 launched: The mission, significanceBest of ExpressSuchana Seth’s questioning, son’s post-mortem reveal he was ‘smothered 36 hrs before she was caught’LifestyleUstad Rashid Khan, the 'assurance for the future of Indian classical music', dies at 55EntertainmentSajini Shinde Ka Viral Video: On letting loose and playing the 'woman card'EntertainmentIMDb's list of 2024's most anticipated Indian films: 3 of top 5 movies share a common actorTrending‘I would prefer to die than eating it’: Netizens react to street food vendor making omelette with Parle-G biscuitsTrendingVideo shows rat-infested IRCTC food stall at railway station in Madhya PradeshSportsWith eye on England Tests, Shreyas Iyer to turn up for Mumbai in Ranji TrophySportsInside Vidit Gujrathi’s preparations for the 2024 Candidates: Team of 3-4 trainers, 2 prep tournaments and costs of over Rs 1 croreOpinionBy sending Bilkis Bano convicts back to jail, SC reasserts its lost powerExplainedWho is the new PM of France, what changes with his appointmentLifestyleDoes this '5-step method to fall asleep fast' work?TechnologyOpenAI fires back at NYT copying allegationsAdvertisementMust ReadSportsWith eye on England Tests, Shreyas Iyer to turn up for Mumbai in Ranji TrophySportsInside Vidit Gujrathi’s preparations for the 2024 Candidates: Team of 3-4 trainers, 2 prep tournaments and costs of over Rs 1 croreSportsParupalli Kashyap to retire; takes on challenge of guiding Kidambi Srikanth first-upTechnologyOpenAI fires back at NYT copying allegationsTechnologySustainable fuel created from whisky-making waste TechnologyWhat does it mean to be 'Wi-Fi 7 Certified'?LifestyleDoes this '5-step method to fall asleep fast' work?AdvertisementEXPRESS OPINIONOpinionBy sending Bilkis Bano convicts back to jail, SC reasserts its lost powerOpinionIn a just society, UPSC obsession would be cruelty. We celebrate itOpinionIndia’s great grain mystery Jan 09: Latest News 01Vibrant Gujarat: AI-based solution to aid police in traffic management and planning02Centre to invest Rs 60,000 cr in river cruise tourism, green vessel development by 2047: Sonowal03World Bank to provide Rs 2,328 crore aid for flood management project04AAP MPs Sanjay Singh & ND Gupta, ex-DCW chief Maliwal file Rajya Sabha poll nominations05After Ranji Trophy debacle against Pondicherry, Delhi sack Yash Dhull as captain, Himmat Singh to take overAdvertisement Arjun Sengupta... read more The chequered history of Bangladesh elections: A timelineElections in Bangladesh: Everything you need to knowWho is Alan Dershowitz, named in the Epstein documents and possibly Israel’s lawyer at The Hague? Subscribe Sign In e-paperPremiumIndiaElections 2024BollywoodOpinionPolitical PulseExplainedScienceCricketSportsWorldBusinessEntertainmentJobsHealthLifestyleTechnologyEducationMovie ReviewEyeTrendingCitiesNewslettersWebSeriesPhotosVideosAudioWeb Stories Trending🎙️ 3 Things PodcastPlay CrosswordLatest NewsPremium StoriesUPSC SpecialHealth & WellnessLive TV close Subscribe Sign In e-paperPremiumIndiaElections 2024BollywoodOpinionPolitical PulseExplainedScienceCricketSportsWorldBusinessEntertainmentJobsHealthLifestyleTechnologyEducationMovie ReviewEyeTrendingCitiesNewslettersWebSeriesPhotosVideosAudioWeb Stories Top Categories Explained News Political Pulse Latest Opinion Mumbai News Delhi News Pune News Bangalore News Bollywood News Health News India News Sports News Lifestyle News Latest News Cricket Tech Reviews Gadgets Mobile & Tabs Food & Wine Elections 2024 Fitness Trending NewsLatest NewsHealth and WellnessEducation NewsBuy All-Access PlanEntertainment NewsTrending NewsPolitical NewsBusiness NewsWhy Subscribe To The Indian ExpressSubscribe To The Indian ExpressBuy Digital PremiumStock Market QuotesIsrael Hamas WarList of Holidays 2024Budget 2024India Budget 2024LATEST STORIESGuardian Minister announces slew contests on the theme of ‘Sri Ram’BMC hospital offers affordable care to men with sexual health issuesMahaRERA implements three-tier scrutiny process for home buyersWhy 2023 was the warmest year ever, and what happens nowSuchana Seth’s questioning, son’s post-mortem reveal he was ‘smothered 36 hours before she was caught’Inside Vidit Gujrathi’s preparations for the 2024 Candidates: Team of 3-4 trainers, 2 prep tournaments and costs of over Rs 1 croreRaveena Tandon: ‘I was offered Karmma Calling ten years back’22,000 staff recruited in Delhi govt depts, civic agencies over past year: L-G House‘Nobody was there for Rajesh Khanna’: Mushtaq Khan recalls working with late actor in his last yearsNadia coaching academy teacher gets 20-year jail for raping 2 girl studentsJwala Gutta and Vishnu Vishal attend Ira Khan’s wedding, see photosWith eye on England Tests, Shreyas Iyer to turn up for Mumbai in Ranji TrophyUstad Rashid Khan, the ‘assurance for the future of Indian classical music’, dies at 55Decode Politics: Uddhav Thackeray’s Sena or Eknath Shinde’s? As hammer comes down tomorrow, a look at what is at stakeUPSC Key—9th January, 2024: Bilkis Bano, Laws on remission and Income InequalityRow over remark: Maldives tour operators seek rapprochement with India, President urges China to send more tourists Follow Us Download Apps The Indian Express website has been rated GREEN for its credibility and trustworthiness by Newsguard, a global service that rates news sources for their journalistic standards. Express Group The Indian Express ieTamil.com The Financial Express ieBangla.com Loksatta ieMalayalam.com Jansatta ieGujarati.com inUth The ExpressGroup MyInsuranceClub Newsletters 26/11 Stories of Strength Ramnath Goenka Excellence in Journalism Awards Online Classes for Kids Light House Journalism Compare Term Insurance Quick Links T&C Privacy Policy Advertise with Us Brand Solutions Contact Us Subscribe Statutory provisions on reporting (sexual offenses) This website follows the DNPA’s code of conduct CSR Copyright © 2024 The Indian Express [P] Ltd. All Rights Reserved