
AI artists are getting death threats.
I’m guessing most aren’t from actual creators. These are mostly the ‘ethics in game journalism / flute protector people. And of course AI artists are getting hate mail. Of course they are. But you know… I didn’t see it coming.
It’s made up my mind about something, though. I’ve been ambivalent, about calling prompt crafters “Artists”, with a capital A. Now that they are braving death threats and hate mail to share their work?
They’re artists now. If they want to identify that way. And, you know, as with pronouns and such… Why do you think your opinion about someone else’s identity is important?
Who decides who is a real man, a real woman, a real artist?
The core reality of being an Artist is that it sucks in significant ways. All fun and joy and humanity in the activity is balanced by various forms of social punishment, and ‘free-market’ abuse.
If you spend too much time making art, to the exclusion of practical pursuits, many will think you’re childish, a narcissist, a parasite. When you DO make a living you are envied, critics point out you don’t DESERVE your money or attention… It sucks. Nobody questions whether you are a real accountant or not. A real brain surgeon. A real insurance adjuster. A real CEO.
If you sell art commercially, you’re a hack and a whore. You’re always derivative, if you sell commercial art, because there is always some tradition you emerge from. (Is Boris Vallejo copying Frank Frazetta, are they both informed by a shared renaissance tradition?) If you sell into gallery spaces, you’re a social climber / poser / con-person laughing all the way to the bank, with your installations of piles of candy and defaced Mona-Lisas, wall mounted urinals and empty canvases, etc etc etc.
So, at the moment, millions of AI artists spend millions of hours at this, don’t make a cent, and get death threats for sharing the work for free….
Sure sounds like art to me!
Or these AI artists sell into the NFT speculative bubbles, and are hated for their financial successes in the same way people hate gallery artists for working that system of getting the world to barf up some cash so you can eat. Many of these NFT / Artist people are doing quite well. Humorously, the people who hate the AI artists are often super into blockchain and NFTs.
Tautology time. Art is art. People make art in lots of ways. Prompts are one way.
The hatred of AI art, as unearned riches, is fucking ridiculous.
Nobody makes art only for the money. Nobody! People who are interested in making money go into the financial industry, because the financial industry is the best way to acquire money, without making anything at all.
Fiddling with markets, tricking one group of rich people into giving money to other groups of rich people, pocketing a cut, makes far more money than actually working, making anything, does.
Some artists who make art figure out how to make money doing it or being near it, but no kid draws a stick figure to get into MoMA.
The written word didn’t destroy the oral tradition, photography didn’t destroy oil painting, digital painting didn’t destroy oils, machine looms didn’t destroy hand weaving and on and on and on and on AND ON.
Everything you you think that technology did to anyone was capitalism doing things to people. Democratic governance letting those things happen.
Capitalism never worked the vast majority of artists.
And, very very soon now, capitalism isn’t going to work well for many, many, many people, who did the right things, went to the right schools, who learned how to do difficult things.
To the individual, I say one thing. Learn the new tools, the new trade, use it to level up, as a quality and productivity booster; get so good they can’t fire you; AI art is good at some things, but at this point, it is never as good as a human in many, many ways.
It’s your job to max out that dimension in your work to stay afloat.
Stop complaining and get on with it.
More broadly, what I am saying is we need a system that doesn’t discard one set of people as technology empowers another, using that disruption to lower wages. (Uber bypassed Taxi medallions, which are starting to look like the years it takes to learn how to do certain digital paintings.)
The owners, the shareholders, pit these groups of workers against each other. Only so many seats in the free-market lifeboat, after all. Sure, half of you are going to drown, but that’s a good thing. For the shareholders. Don’t you deserve to drown, really? So someone somewhere can get much richer?
Take two steps back, instead of one; capitalism never worked for the creative class. Ever. The fact that we have so much great work is a fucking accident. Orthogonal. The market never monetized Van Gogh in a way where he supported himself. The estate, the shareholders as the work became a product, did.
We need the arts, the humanities, they literally make us better people, more humane, in studies I have linked to and can link to again, and the ‘free’ market is a shit way to pay for the humanities.
If you find yourself hating AI art, support traditional artists for fuck’s sake. Buy a fucking painting, and if you have never bought a goddamn painting, shut the fuck up.
Stop following people who share AI art or make it. Don’t have gay sex if you don’t want to, don’t get gay married if you don’t want to, don’t change your gender if you don’t want to, don’t cut your dick or tits off if you don’t want to, don’t smoke pot if you don’t want to, don’t get an abortion if you don’t want to…
CHRIST this shit isn’t hard to figure out.
How to be a good person, I mean.



